28+ US States’ Attorneys General Call for Repair Legislation

28+ US States’ Attorneys General Call for Repair Legislation

Every week there are too many developments in the world of repair for any mere mortal to keep track of. Fortunately, the folks over at the Fight to Repair newsletter are here to help: recapping the most important repair news for iFixit readers. As a special offer, iFixit.com readers can claim a free, 60-day premium membership to the Fight to Repair newsletter. Visit fighttorepair.substack.com/ifixit to claim your premium membership!

A bipartisan group of Attorneys General representing over half of the US states and Guam is urging Congress to pass right-to-repair laws.

In a letter addressed to the heads of the House Energy and Commerce Committee and the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, the attorneys general urged Congress to pass “expansive Right to Repair legislation” covering automobiles, electronics, and agricultural equipment.

A radio, tv, VCR, and audio repair shop, advertising service on 18 different brands
This Boston radio, TV, VCR, and audio repair shop is part of a dying breed—and without legal protection, it won’t last.
Photo via Nick Bianco on Flickr.

“The Right-to-Repair is a bipartisan issue that impacts every consumer, household, and farm in a time of increasing inflation. It is about ensuring that consumers have choices as to who, where, when and at what cost their vehicles can be repaired,” the letter (PDF) reads.

“As State Attorneys General, we seek federal partners to provide necessary changes to the law that will better protect America’s consumers, particularly at this time of economic uncertainty.”

Signers include the state attorneys general from Alaska, Arizona, California, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Indiana, Idaho, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Vermont, Washington, and Wisconsin, as well as the attorneys general from the District of Columbia, Guam, and the Northern Mariana Islands. 

A number of right to repair laws are pending on Capitol Hill including:

  • The Right to Equitable and Professional Auto Industry Repair (REPAIR) Act would require automakers to give the same access to data and maintenance tools to independent repair shops that they do to their dealerships.
  • The Saving Money on Auto Repair Transportation (SMART) Act would limit the time for which automakers can enforce patents on collision repair parts against aftermarket suppliers. The attorneys argue that these changes would help lower repair prices and widen the options available to consumers.
  • Repair advocates also expect the reintroduction of the Freedom to Repair Act, which was other Right to Repair bills were also considered last session.

Currently, Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) in most industries can restrict access to these crucial parts and information, which results in higher costs for repairs and replacement parts. Those restrictions also make it more difficult for independent repair providers and small businesses to compete and limit the ability of consumers to repair their own vehicles. Together, those factors lead to less choice, increased costs and longer waits, encouraging consumers to replace- rather than repair broken goods. That impacts both the environment and consumer finances.

What the AGs Are Saying

  • California Attorney General Rob Bonta emphasizes that passing legislation to prevent manufacturers from limiting independent repair would create a competitive marketplace for repairing various products, including vehicles and agricultural equipment. Allowing consumers to repair or replace their products on their own terms could reduce waste and drive down costs.
  • The Attorney General of Illinois argued that the monopoly on repair caused by OEMs results in increased prices for consumers and urged Congress to consider proposed legislation from the 117th Congress. Despite widespread public support for right-to-repair legislation, these bills were not passed.
  • Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel sees passing right-to-repair legislation as a way to protect farmers and consumers by allowing small businesses to compete against closed systems favored by OEMs and to repair agricultural equipment at a reasonable cost.

“Consumers just want to fix their stuff, and attorneys general across the country are heeding their call,” said Nathan Proctor of US PIRG. “Right to Repair is common sense, and this incredible, bipartisan display of support shows, people from all across America support making it the law of the land.”

Other News

Workers repair a broken wind turbine via cranes
Wind turbine repair: A high-flying job.
Photo via Rudolph Ammann on Flickr.
  • Tesla is facing scrutiny from Chinese regulators: Quality and safety concerns from China related to Tesla’s vehicles, including issues with battery fires, sudden acceleration, and other defects have caused increased oversight into the EV giant. This could potentially lead to a recall of tens of thousands of Tesla vehicles in China and harm the company’s reputation and sales in the world’s largest auto market. In the U.S., Tesla Inc was named in a pair of proposed class action lawsuits in March that accused the company of unlawfully curbing competition for maintenance and replacement parts for its electric vehicles, forcing owners to pay more and wait longer for repair services in violation of U.S. antitrust laws.
  • EU’s plan to reduce e-waste is criticized by environmentalists: Under the newly proposed EU repair rules, sellers would legally have to offer repairs for products covered by a guarantee, while manufacturers must offer repairs for certain technically repairable products. The EU also wants to introduce quality standards for repair services and create nationwide portals for consumers to find repair services and refurbished products. However, the rules will not immediately apply to smartphones and tablets, which are significant sources of e-waste. Campaign group Right to Repair Europe said the proposals don’t go far enough to address the cost of repairs.
  • Canada eyes USB-C standardization: Canada’s 2023 federal budget includes plans to look into implementing a standardized charging port across the country to reduce electronic waste and save Canadians money. The move follows the EU’s passing of legislation mandating the use of USB-C on electronic devices. The budget also mentions implementing a right-to-repair framework for home appliances and electronics in 2024 to reduce high repair fees and promote repairing over buying new products.
  • If you own a 50-year-old RV, you must believe you can fix it: Scott Gilbertson writes in Wired of his decision to trade a suburban home for him and his family for a 1969 Dodge Travco, a half-century-old RV. “I bought it out of a muddled sense of self-reliance born of stubbornness and ideals,” Gilbertson explains. “I wanted them to know that anything worth fixing can be fixed, and anything that can’t be fixed isn’t worth having. But sitting there in the heat of the California sun on Highway 168 that afternoon, the bus felt more like a giant check my ego had written that my fumbling fingers and tools could not cash.”
  • Wind turbine repair is expected to create 20,000 jobs: The UK-based group Coalition for Wind Industry Circularity (CWIC) says infrastructure repair related to wind power could add thousands of jobs to the nation’s economy. They also argue that this expansion of wind power will prevent 800,000 tonnes of parts from being scrapped by repairing and re-using broken wind turbines. A UK supply chain capable of refurbishing ten parts of a single turbine could access a European-wide market worth almost £10bn to UK GDP between 2025 and 2035.
  • Vermont debates agricultural repair legislation: A bill in Vermont is being considered that would require agricultural equipment manufacturers like John Deere, Tigercat, or Caterpillar to offer equipment parts, manuals, codes, and diagnostics to owners at a fair market value. Trade organizations claim these items are intellectual property or qualify as trade secrets and opposition to the bill ranges from constitutional objections to concerns that farmers and loggers could override emissions controls or safety features built into the equipment. Advocates point out that by restricting repair access, equipment manufacturers may be violating the very Clean Air Act they’re hiding behind.
  • Repair Cafes are attracting younger volunteers: Younger volunteers interested in sustainable solutions and fighting the throw-away mentality are increasingly joining Repair Cafes. Specifically, in Amsterdam, organizations have reported an increase in younger volunteers, who bring skills and enthusiasm to the teams that are more traditionally staffed by older members.
  • 83% of e-waste produced globally is not collected: With 53.6 million metric tons of e-waste produced annually worldwide, the World Economic Forum says a lack of collection and reuse is a major missed opportunity for the circular economy. Although incentives or regulations may be required to increase e-waste recycling rates, concerns around sensitive information contained in electronic products need to be addressed. E-waste represents the fastest-growing waste stream globally, but separating and sorting components for recycling can be labor intensive.
Every day, the world generates e-waste that weighs as much as 100 blue whales