It took a while to convince myself, but the display was the issue. I guess I just got confused because there were no problems with the display when I went back to the old motherboard … until just recently. Plugging in a secondary display confirmed that all was well. The new motherboard is working fine and does not really need anything special to activate. After I completely unplugged and reinstalled the display everything was visible and working normally!
It’s so easy to crack the screen here. I recommend using heat to soften the bond and avoid cracking the screen. Ideally a heating pad ($$$), but a heat gun or hair dryer also does the trick. I’ve seen a temperature range of 80-90 C (matching specs from a heating pad). I heated a pizza stone to temperature to make a homemade heating pad. That worked to soften the adhesive here.